Casely vs. Pela
Share
Consumers increasingly demand environmental responsibility alongside phone protection. Two brands have taken center stage in this space: Casely, famous for its artistic prints and heavy-duty protective cases, and Pela, the pioneer of the world's first fully compostable phone case. While both brands market themselves to eco-conscious buyers, their manufacturing materials, drop ratings, aesthetic options, and MagSafe integrations are completely different.
In our testing laboratory, our diagnostic experts put both brands through drop, tensile strength, and environmental degradation testing. Below is our detailed breakdown of how Casely and Pela compare.
Casely vs. Pela Specification Matrix
| Feature / Metric | Casely Classic | Casely Bold | Pela Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material Base | Recycled Polycarbonate & TPU | Recycled Dual-Layer TPU/PC | Flaxstic (Flax shive + plant polymer) |
| Drop Protection | 4 Feet | 8 Feet | 6 Feet |
| Compostable? | No (Recyclable only) | No (Recyclable only) | Yes (100% home compostable) |
| MagSafe Magnet | Optional | Optional | No (Qi compatible only) |
| Texture & Feel | Glossy / Smooth | Rigid bumper, smooth back | Matte, warm, slightly textured |
| Design Style | High-fashion, graphic prints | High-fashion, prints | Solid colors, debossed eco-art |
Detailed Brand Showdowns
1. Material Composition & Sustainability
The most critical difference between these two brands lies in what happens to the case when you are done using it. - Pela: Pela cases are made from Flaxstic—a proprietary blend of compostable bioplastics (compostable polymers) and flax shive. Flax shive is an agricultural byproduct that would otherwise be burned. When you upgrade your phone, you can throw your Pela case directly into your backyard compost bin, where it will fully decompose into organic soil within 6 to 12 months. - Casely: Casely uses recycled plastics and ocean-bound plastics for their cases. They also use biodegradable packaging and donate a portion of their proceeds to environmental charities. However, Casely cases are still bound with traditional polymers, meaning they will not decompose in a compost bin. They must be sent to specialized recycling programs to avoid ending up in a landfill.
2. Drop Protection and Physical Durability
In our laboratory tests, our testing team analyzed shock transfer during corner drops: - Casely Bold: The Bold series features a dual-layer design with thick rubber bumpers, air pocket corners, and a hard backplate. In our drop tests from 8 feet onto concrete, the Casely Bold case protected the iPhone perfectly. The rigid frame prevented any twisting or screen flexion. - Pela Case: Pela cases are single-piece, flexible covers. Because the Flaxstic material is naturally soft and elastic, it absorbs shocks incredibly well. However, because it lacks a rigid inner polycarbonate frame, Pela cases can stretch slightly over time. In our 6-foot drop tests, the phone survived, but the case suffered minor cosmetic gouges in the soft plant material. If you want to compare Pela to other minimalist cases, check out Burga iPhone 16 Case Review.
3. Aesthetics, Prints, and Finishes
- Casely: Casely is a design powerhouse. They collaborate with independent artists to release new collections monthly, featuring metallic foils, glitter, floral designs, and bold geometric patterns. The prints are embedded into the plastic so they do not peel.
- Pela: Pela focuses on natural, earthy aesthetics. Their cases are mostly solid, muted colors (like sage green, lavender, and terracotta) with small flecks of natural flax fiber visible. Pela also offers laser-engraved editions featuring line art of mountains, animals, and waves. The look is beautifully minimalist but cannot match the vibrant colors of Casely.
4. MagSafe Compatibility and Magnet Strength
During our magnetic alignment tests, our diagnostic experts measured how well each case interfaces with MagSafe charging stands and car mounts. - Casely: Casely’s MagSafe models contain a high-quality neodymium magnet ring sandwiched between the inner and outer layers. The magnetic connection registered a holding force of 1.3 lbs on our force gauge. This holds securely on bumpy roads when using a magnetic car vent mount. - Pela: Pela does not embed metallic magnets in their standard cases, as metal components interfere with the home composting process. Pela cases rely on the thinness of their material to allow MagSafe charging to work, but the magnetic hold is extremely weak. A MagSafe wallet will slide off immediately. If you require MagSafe mounting, you should avoid Pela or purchase their adhesive magnetic adapter rings.
Step-by-Step: How to Properly Compost Your Pela Case
When you upgrade your device, do not throw your Pela case in the regular trash. Follow these instructions to compost it properly:
- Remove the Phone: Take your phone out of the case.
- Separate Metal Components: Verify that you have removed any adhesive metal plates or rings you may have added to the back.
- Clean the Case: Wash off any sticky residue or food particles.
- Chop It Up (Optional): To accelerate the composting process, use heavy scissors to cut the case into small 1-inch squares. This increases the surface area for soil microbes.
- Place in Compost Bin: Toss the pieces into your backyard compost pile or municipal green bin. Ensure your compost pile is active, warm, and turned regularly.
- Verify Decay: Over the next 6 months, the case will break down into organic matter. For device maintenance during your upgrade, consult Apple Support or iFixit for recycling old phone electronics.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Are Pela cases dirty or sticky because they are made of plants?
No. Pela cases feel dry, smooth, and slightly textured, similar to a premium matte silicone case. The flax flecks are embedded inside the polymer and do not flake off. The material does not attract pocket lint.
Do Casely cases yellow over time?
Casely's clear cases are treated with a UV-resistant coating. However, like all clear TPU cases, they will eventually show slight yellowing along the borders after months of exposure to skin oils and sunlight. Casely's printed designs on the Bold and Classic series do not yellow because the backplate is opaque.
Can I recycle my old Casely case?
Yes. Casely runs a recycling program where you can mail in your old cases (from any brand) to be properly recycled rather than thrown into a landfill.
Which case is better for people with active outdoor lifestyles?
If you are hiking, camping, or climbing, the Casely Bold is superior because its rigid outer shell provides better protection against sharp rocks. However, if you are concerned about leaving plastic micro-particles in nature, Pela is the preferred environmental option. For tactical alternatives, check out Rokform Alternatives.